In Batman Begins and The Dark Knight Christopher Nolan, his brother Jonathan, David Goyer and Christian Bale have created the greatest celluloid Batman thus far, and also, arguably, the best comic book movie ever made. There is so much rumour about a third instalment that the supposed villains featured would be anyone from The Riddler, played by Eddie Murphy, to Catwoman, played by Cher. So the question is who would you like to see in the movie? Which characters and played by whom? What would you like the film to be about?
The first film, Batman Begins, was about fear. The Dark Knight was about corruption and the nature of heroism. For the third, in what I believe should end as a trilogy, I believe that the film should continue to explore the nature of heroism and also duality. The perfect villains to explore this concept, I think, would be The Penguin and Catwoman.
The Penguin comes from a place of high society just like Bruce Wayne. I would see him portrayed in the film as not the claw handed, sharp toothed, ice water bathing cartoon that the comic books show him as, but rather as a Gangster fighting for the top spot in Gotham's underworld. His name could come from the fact that he waddles (he could have a foot deformity from polio as a child), dresses well, and has a prominent nose. Many gangsters have nicknames either amongst themselves or given to them by the media. I mentioned that, like Bruce Wayne, the penguins origins stem from high society, so why, you ask, has he become a gangster? This is where the penguin is tweaked to serve the films purposes. As far as I know there is no real established origin for The Penguin so, again for the purpose of showing his dual nature to Batman, why not have him be the victim of a terrible tragedy. For instance, why not have the young Oswald Cobblepot be orphaned as a child in the exact same way as what happened to the Waynes. Bruce Wayne saw tragedy and decided to become a force that opposed injustice. Cobblepot will take the decision that he will never be a victim again. Rather than want to protect others his self pity turns to rage and he decides that to survive in the harsh world of Gotham you have to be at the top of the food chain.
Catwoman will be born out of necessity. Forced by his true outlaw status, as transpired from The Dark Knight, Batman has been forced to make a triage style choice about where to concentrate his crime fighting efforts. Batman decides to concentrate on cutting the head of the snake and takes on the upper echelons of the mob but, as an effect of doing so, is now neglecting victims at the street level. Enter Catwoman. Keeping her Frank Miller written origin as a hooker who fights back in mind, Selina Kyle would be inspired by the idea of Batman but not has the resources to tackle crime from the moral high ground that Bruce Wayne can afford. In order to bankroll her fight on crime Catwoman would have to take on a Robin Hood esque approach, stealing the money from the criminals that she takes down. The question then becomes: should stop her? Is she any worse than he might have been had he not had billions of dollars to fund him? To use paraphrase a line from The Dark Knight, spoken by a Batman impersonator, what gives him the right?
I think both villains would present an interesting inner struggle for Batman, but lets not forget the outer struggles too. The movie would be action packed between the Penguin's gang war with the controlling mob with Batman in the middle, to Catwoman's battles on the streets and, of course, with Batman himself.
Now the fun part, by which, of course, I mean casting.
Toby Jones as The Penguin
As Truman Capote in Infamous (2006) the diminutive actor said "you have to be tough to be tiny". The phrase stuck is my head and after seeing the character actors work in that film, The Mist (2007) and Frost/Nixon (2008), I think he has the right qualities to make The Penguin into a real and empathetic character that fit comfortably into the world that the Nolan brothers have created.
Emily Blunt as Catwoman
Not only is Blunt stunning but she is emerging as the next big thing in Hollywood after stand-out roles in The Devil Wears Prada (2006) and The Young Victoria (2009), and has shown she has the versatility to play a complex character (as I would hope Selina Kyle would be presented as) in both those films. Look for her earlier roles in the British film My Summer of Love (2004) and the BBC's Gideon's Daughter (2005) to see more of this great actress and why I think she could go toe-to-toe with Christian Bale.
Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje as Waylon 'Killer Croc' Jones
See Brian Azzarello's depiction of Killer Croc in his Joker graphic novel for an idea of how he would appear in the Nolan series. The character was once depicted as drug/arms dealer with an unfortunate skin condition, though here I would depict him more as muscle for The Penguin, I would, of course, follow the skin condition, rather than (ridiculous) monster, route. Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje was terrifying as sociopath convict Simon Adebesi in HBO's Oz and was brutal as the character, Majestic, in Get Rich or Die Tryin' (2005) and would bring the appropriate level of menace to the character.
I'm sure that whatever the Nolan's have planned for the third instalment they will not fail to impress, until that day however, I'll be playing this movie in my head.